Sahil Alvi

Tag: Michael Burry

Newmont Mining: A Value Stock in a Growth Sector

by sahilalvi on Jul.31, 2011, under Finance

Newmont Mining - North AmericaWhat gold producer sells at 2 times book value?

Which global miner has the lowest beta among its peer group?

Which resources company trades lower than 12 times its earnings?

The answer: Newmont Mining (NEM).

Newmont Mining — a Gold and Copper exploration and production company with mining operations spanning five continents around the world with “proven and probable gold reserves of 93.5 million attributable ounces, copper reserves of 9.4 billion attributable pounds” and an aggregate land position of approximately 27,458 square miles (71,118 square kilometers).

In 2010, the company had attributable gold sales of 5.4 million ounces and equity copper sales of 327 million pounds. Its recent acquisition of the Conga Project in Peru and Tanami Shaft Project in Australia will be adding “400,000 attributable ounces of gold and up to 100 million pounds of copper production per year” by 2015.

According to Newmont’s website, these were but a few highlights from the company’s performance in 2010:

  • Record revenues of $9.5 billion, up 24% from 2009;
  • Record net cash from continuing operations of $3.2 billion, up 109% from 2009;
  • Gold operating margin increased 30% from 2009 on an average realized gold price increase of 25%.

Pick any one of those highlights and one can assume that the company being discussed is a growth company (with a momentum stock).

The stock, however, has been trading in a fairly narrow 52-week range of $50.05 and $65.50 with a P-E multiple that is more reflective of a value stock.

Is there a reason why it should not break out above its upper limit of the trading range?

According to Vickers Stock Research: “NEM pays an annual dividend of $1.20 which, at its current stock price, produces a yield of 2.16%. This is the largest of any company in the Gold & Silver industry, where the average yield is 1.56%…”

According to a company press release: “The third quarter 2011 dividend of $.30 per share (a 50% increase over $.20 per share for Q2, 2011) was declared in consideration of Newmont’s second quarter 2011 average realized gold sales price of $1,501 an ounce .”

In contrast, the company’s 2010 Gold Operating Margin is $737/oz.

At the time of writing this piece in late July, 2011, Gold has crossed the $1600 per ounce mark and is trading comfortably above that level. In a “risk-off” environment, when Gold keeps breaching its all-time highs on a regular basis, Newmont Mining (one of the largest Gold producers) deserves to enjoy a little more buoyancy in its stock than what it has experienced in the recent past. On the one hand, given its exposure to gold production, Newmont is poised to gain in a continued period of “risk-off,” de-leveraging global economy where fiat currencies are being debased across several major jurisdictions. On the other hand, even in a “risk-on” environment when Copper demand begins to soar again thanks to expansionary tailwinds in a rapidly urbanizing global economy, Newmont — being one of the largest copper producers in the world — is positioned to perform exceedingly well as a “long Copper” play.

At an operating margin of over 42% and a net profit margin of approximately 32%, Newmont is one of the most profitable minerals and metals producers — large or small — in the world. The miner enjoys gross margins that are more than 10% higher than its peer group. Furthermore, Newmont is sitting on cash and cash equivalents of more than $4 billion within an asset base of $25.7 billion.

Over the last 5 years, the company’s Earnings per Share (EPS) has grown a staggering 49.41%.

Newmont Mining - AsiaAt a P-E ratio that is higher only to Freeport-McMoRan (FCX) within its peer group, Newmont is a “value” stock in a growth sector.

Kinross Gold (KGC), for example, trades at a healthy 16.37 its earnings and Goldcorp (GG) trades at almost twice as much as Newmont at a P-E multiple of 22.13. By the time one gets to AngloGold Ashanti (AU), one is looking at an unbelievable P-E multiple of 105.85.

Whether you look at Return-on-equity or Return-on-assets, Newmont ranks among the top 3 of its peer group.

Here’s a tale of relative value analysis that is as stark as it gets for companies that are delivering virtually identical numbers: The company that Newmont resembles most in terms of gross revenues, net profits, net profit margins, and a whole host of other metrics is Barrick Gold (ABX).

Exhibit 1: Profitability


Net profit margin

Gross margin

EBITD margin

Operating margin

Newmont Mining





Barrick Gold





Here’s a rhetorical question: Which company is more profitable?

Exhibit 2: Debt


Long-term debt to assets

Total debt to assets

Long-term debt to equity

Total debt to equity

Newmont Mining





Barrick Gold





Which of these two companies is less indebted?

Exhibit 3: Returns


Return on avg assets

Return on avg equity

Return on investment

Newmont Mining




Barrick Gold




Again, which company provides a higher return?

Exhibit 4: Pricing


P/E ratio


book ratio


sales ratio

Newmont Mining




Barrick Gold




Finally, let us look at the all important metric of reserves:

As of December 31, 2010, Newmont had “proven and probable gold reserves of 93.5 million attributable ounces, copper reserves of 9.4 billion attributable pounds.” Barrick, on the other hand, had “140 million ounces of proven and probable gold reserves. In addition, Barrick has 6.5 billion pounds of copper reserves and 1.07 billion ounces of silver contained within gold reserves.”

Barrick has roughly 50% more gold reserves — which admittedly would allow it to command a premium over Newmont based purely on the metric of gold reserves. Gold, however, is not the complete story. When it comes to copper reserves, Newmont Mining has roughly 1/3rd more than Barrick Gold.

In a certain snapshot in time, if we consider valuations based purely on gold reserves (and silver within it), Barrick should be roughly 50% more valuable as a company. That said, given that Newmont has a third more copper than Barrick, it would recoup approximately 7.5% of the value back (adjusting for the price of copper vis-a-vis gold).

Here’s the clincher: With all these metrics where Newmont beats Barrick Gold consistently (except in the key metric of gold reserves), guess which company is more valuable (as of late July 2011)?

It is Barrick Gold at $47.54 billion.

And, what’s Newmont Mining’s market cap?

$27.45 billion.

So, the market is placing 75% more value on Barrick Gold than it does on Newmont Mining. It is established, however, that even when considering mining reserves as a sole determinant of value, Barrick is a little over 40% more valuable than Newmont.

So, which company would you pick based on the above valuations? What company’s stock would have greater upside potential?

In conclusion, one can’t help but wonder: Is Newmont undervalued…by as much as 35% or more?

Seth Klarman: How’s that for margin of safety?

Michael Burry: Is this enough of a value stock for you?

Need one say (or question) more.

Sources: Reuters, Google Finance, Vickers Stock Research, Cooper Financial Research, Barrick Gold, Newmont Mining.

Disclosure: The author owns a long position in the company. All data has been sourced from publicly-available sources.

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark
Leave a Comment :, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , more...

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!